Back to Course
Direct and Indirect Speech
The Fundamentals of Reporting
Direct speech repeats the exact words spoken, while indirect speech (reported speech) conveys the same meaning using a Reported Clause introduced by a Reporting Verb.
Exactitude: Direct speech uses quotation marks to isolate the speaker's original words.
Integration: Indirect speech integrates the message into the narrator's sentence, often using the conjunction 'that'.
Say vs Tell: 'Say' does not require an object ('He said that...'), while 'tell' requires one ('He told me that...').
Ask: Used for questions and polite requests — 'She asked if...' or 'She asked me to...'
The Rule of Backshifting
Backshifting is the grammatical process of shifting tenses 'one step back' into the past when the reporting verb is in a past tense.
Core Principle: Each tense moves one step deeper into the past — Present becomes Past, Past becomes Past Perfect.
No Backshift Needed: When the reporting verb is present tense ('He says...'), the reported clause keeps its original tense.
Universal Truths Exception: Facts that are always true ('The earth orbits the sun') may stay in present tense even with a past reporting verb.
Already Past Perfect: If the original speech is already in Past Perfect, it cannot shift further — it stays as Past Perfect.
Complete Backshift Table
Direct → Indirect (when reporting verb is past)
•
Present Simple (is/go) → Past Simple (was/went)
•
Present Continuous (is going) → Past Continuous (was going)
•
Present Perfect (has gone) → Past Perfect (had gone)
•
Present Perfect Continuous (has been going) → Past Perfect Continuous (had been going)
•
Past Simple (went) → Past Perfect (had gone)
•
Past Continuous (was going) → Past Perfect Continuous (had been going)
•
Past Perfect (had gone) → Past Perfect (had gone) — no change
•
will → would
•
can → could
•
may → might
•
must → had to (obligation) / must (logical deduction)
Changes in Person, Place, and Time
When moving from direct to indirect speech, deictic words (words that point to specific times, places, or people) must shift to reflect the narrator's perspective.
Pronoun Transformation: First person ('I', 'me', 'my', 'we') shifts to match the original speaker (third person 'he/she/they'), while second person ('you') shifts to match the listener.
Spatial Shift: 'Here' becomes 'there', and 'this' becomes 'that'.
Time and Place Conversion Table
•
now → then / at that time
•
today → that day
•
tonight → that night
•
yesterday → the day before / the previous day
•
tomorrow → the next day / the following day
•
last week → the week before / the previous week
•
next month → the following month
•
ago → before / earlier
•
here → there
•
this → that
•
these → those
Reporting Questions: The Word Order Trap
Reported questions lose their question mark and abandon the Inversion found in direct questions, adopting standard statement word order instead.
Statement Order: Instead of Verb-Subject ('Where are you?'), use Subject-Verb ('...where I was').
Wh- Questions: Keep the original question word (who, what, where, why, how) as the linker — no extra conjunction needed.
Yes/No Questions: Use 'if' or 'whether' to introduce the reported question when no question word is present.
Do/Does/Did Removal: The auxiliary 'do/does/did' used to form questions is dropped entirely — 'Where did he go?' becomes '...where he had gone', not '...where did he go'.
Reporting Commands, Requests, and Advice
Imperatives (commands, requests, advice) are reported using a reporting verb + object + to-infinitive, never by backshifting the imperative form.
Commands: Use 'told' or 'ordered' + object + to-infinitive. 'Close the door!' → He told me to close the door.
Requests: Use 'asked' or 'requested' + object + to-infinitive. 'Please help me' → She asked him to help her.
Negative Imperatives: Add 'not' before the infinitive. 'Don't touch that!' → She told him not to touch that.
Advice: Use 'advised' + object + to-infinitive. 'You should exercise more' → The doctor advised her to exercise more.
Choosing the Right Reporting Verb
The choice of Reporting Verb affects both the meaning and the grammatical structure that follows it.
Verb + that-clause: said, explained, mentioned, claimed, admitted, denied, insisted — 'He admitted that he had made a mistake.'
Verb + object + that-clause: told, informed, reminded, assured, convinced — 'She reminded me that the deadline was Friday.'
Verb + to-infinitive: agreed, offered, promised, refused, threatened — 'He promised to return the book.'
Verb + object + to-infinitive: asked, told, ordered, advised, encouraged, warned — 'She warned him not to go alone.'
Verb + -ing: suggested, recommended, denied, admitted — 'He suggested going to the park.' (alternative to that-clause)
Say vs Tell — Quick Rule
•
SAY: never takes an indirect object — 'He said that...' (✓) / 'He said me that...' (✗)
•
TELL: always takes an indirect object — 'He told me that...' (✓) / 'He told that...' (✗)
•
Exception: fixed phrases — tell a lie, tell the truth, tell a story, tell the time
Application Strategy
Worked Examples
Problem Statement
Convert 'I went to the market yesterday,' said Sarah.
Past Simple to Past PerfectTime adverbial changePronoun shift
Strategic Toolkit
$\text{Direct} \rightarrow \text{Indirect (Backshift)}$
Step 1
Analyze the Reporting Verb
The reporting verb 'said' is in the past tense, which triggers backshifting in the reported clause.
Step 2
Shift the Tense
The direct verb 'went' is Past Simple. Following the rule of backshifting, it must move to the Past Perfect.
$\text{went} \rightarrow \text{had gone}$
Step 3
Adjust Pronouns and Time
The speaker 'I' (Sarah) becomes 'she'. The time marker 'yesterday' becomes 'the previous day'.
$\text{yesterday} \rightarrow \text{the previous day}$
Step 4
Construct Final Sentence
Combine the elements: Sarah said that she had gone to the market the previous day.
Problem Statement
Convert 'Do you like coffee?' he asked me.
Yes/No question transformationRemoval of auxiliary 'do'Word order shift
Strategic Toolkit
$\text{Question} \rightarrow \text{if/whether} + \text{Statement Order}$
Step 1
Identify Question Type
This is a Yes/No question, so we must use 'if' or 'whether' to link the reported clause.
Step 2
Remove Inversion and Auxiliaries
In reported speech, the auxiliary 'do' used for questions is removed, and we return to Subject-Verb order.
$\text{Do you like...?} \rightarrow \dots \text{if I liked}$
Step 3
Apply Backshifting
The Present Simple verb 'like' shifts back to the Past Simple 'liked'.
$\text{like} \rightarrow \text{liked}$
Step 4
Final Result
Combine: He asked me if I liked coffee.
Problem Statement
Convert 'Don't open the window,' the nurse told the patient.
Negative imperativeto-infinitive structureReporting verb choice
Strategic Toolkit
$\text{Imperative} \rightarrow \text{told + object + (not) + to-infinitive}$
Step 1
Identify the Sentence Type
This is a negative imperative (command). Imperatives use a completely different reporting pattern — we do NOT backshift; we use the to-infinitive.
Step 2
Choose Reporting Verb and Structure
'Told' already takes an object ('the patient'). The structure is: told + object + not + to-infinitive.
$\text{Don't open} \rightarrow \text{not to open}$
Step 3
Construct Final Sentence
The nurse told the patient not to open the window. Note: no 'that', no backshifting — just the infinitive construction.
Problem Statement
Convert 'Why can't you come tomorrow?' she asked him.
Wh-question reportingModal backshiftingNegative contractionTime adverbial change
Strategic Toolkit
$\text{Wh-Question} \rightarrow \text{asked + wh-word + Statement Order}$
Step 1
Identify the Linker
This is a wh-question ('Why'), so the question word itself serves as the linker — no 'if' or 'whether' needed.
Step 2
Fix Word Order and Backshift Modal
Remove inversion: 'can't you come' becomes 'he couldn't come'. The modal 'can' backshifts to 'could'.
$\text{can't} \rightarrow \text{couldn't}$
Step 3
Shift Time Adverbial
'Tomorrow' becomes 'the following day' to reflect the narrator's time frame.
$\text{tomorrow} \rightarrow \text{the following day}$
Step 4
Construct Final Sentence
She asked him why he couldn't come the following day.
Memorize formulas
The 'One Step Back' Rule
To backshift, move the tense one step deeper into the past on the grammar timeline.
Formula
$\text{Pres} \rightarrow \text{Past} \rightarrow \text{Past Perfect}$
Reported Question Order
Remember: ASV (Ask + Subject + Verb). Never use question order in reported speech.
Formula
$\text{He asked} + \text{wh-word/if} + \text{Subject} + \text{Verb}$
Imperative Reporting Pattern
Commands and requests use to-infinitive, not backshifting.
Formula
$\text{told/asked} + \text{object} + (\text{not}) + \text{to-infinitive}$
Review
1
Which of the following is the correct indirect form of: 'I have been waiting for two hours,' she said.
Ans
She said that she had been waiting for two hours.
Review
Tap to reveal
Backshift the continuous perfect tense
The reporting verb is in the past, so the present perfect continuous in direct speech becomes past perfect continuous in indirect speech. The duration phrase stays unchanged.
She said that she had been waiting for two hours.
2
Select the correct transformation for: 'Where do you live?' the officer asked me.
Ans
The officer asked me where I lived.
Review
Tap to reveal
Convert the wh-question into statement order
After the wh-word, indirect speech uses normal subject-verb order, so the question becomes a statement. The auxiliary 'do' is removed in the process.
where I lived
3
Report the following: 'The earth revolves around the sun,' said the professor. Which change is INCORRECT?
Ans
The professor said that the earth revolved around the sun.
Review
Tap to reveal
Keep a universal truth in the present tense
Scientific facts do not backshift in indirect speech because they remain true regardless of when they are reported. Only the reporting verb changes to the past.
The earth revolves around the sun.
4
Convert the sentence to indirect speech: 'I will see you here tomorrow,' John told me.
Ans
John told me he would see me there the next day.
Review
Tap to reveal
Shift the pronouns and time/place markers
Indirect speech requires changing the speaker, listener, and deictic words to fit the new reporting context. Here becomes there, and tomorrow becomes the next day.
John told me he would see me there the next day.
5
Choose the correct reported form of: 'Please close the door quietly,' the librarian said to us.
Ans
The librarian requested us to close the door quietly.
Review
Tap to reveal
Report the request with a to-infinitive
A polite command or request is normally changed into reporting verb + object + to-infinitive. The word 'please' is not repeated because the request is already expressed by the verb.
The librarian requested us to close the door quietly.
6
Which sentence correctly reports: 'I may not be able to attend the meeting,' the director said.
Ans
The director said that he might not be able to attend the meeting.
Review
Tap to reveal
Backshift the modal of possibility
When a past reporting verb is used, 'may' usually changes to 'might' in indirect speech. That keeps the idea of uncertainty instead of turning it into ability or certainty.
The director said that he might not be able to attend the meeting.
7
'He said me that he was tired.' What is wrong with this sentence?
Ans
'Said' should be 'told' because an indirect object ('me') follows the reporting verb.
Review
Tap to reveal
Use 'told' when an object follows
The phrase has an indirect object ('me'), so the reporting verb must be 'told' rather than 'said'. 'Say' does not directly take an object in this structure.
He told me that he was tired.
8
Report: 'Had you already eaten before you came?' she asked him.
Ans
She asked him if he had already eaten before he had come.
Review
Tap to reveal
Link the yes/no question with if or whether
Reported yes/no questions are introduced with 'if' or 'whether', and the word order becomes statement order. The earlier past perfect stays as past perfect, while the later past simple backshifts.
She asked him if he had already eaten before he had come.
Question 1 of 8
0:00
1
Which of the following is the correct indirect form of: 'I have been waiting for two hours,' she said.